Tuesday, May 25, 2010

Deep Genealogy, DNA, and Ancient Celtic Histories

The Storms River Mouth Cave was very likely one of the shoreline abodes of some of my ancient stone age ancestors. Though I had never been there before, it was a very familiar place, a place of epiphanies like Elijah's cave. My roots in Africa are very real. It is equally real on other distant shores: Scotland, Ireland, going back even to the Black Sea! Once, sitting on a beach on Mull looking across to the sacred island Iona in the Hebrides there were the same familiar feelings that "this was home".

The reason for this excursion deep into my own personal history is simple. Calvin Miller in The Path of Celtic Prayer expresses it well, "I wanted to find the flame again. For it is sometimes by looking at the past that the present amends its dead soul, and there is a chance that the future is born with new vitality." (p.6)

To confirm these connections, I arranged a Y-Chromosome DNA analysis tracking my paternal line down time and back some 30,000 years into my own misty antiquity. The results were intriguing. This was a far deeper cave...

"Haplogroup R is defined by a DNA marker known as M207. Everyone who carries this marker today descends from a common paternal ancestor who lived about 30,000 years ago in west Asia. To date, over thirty subclades of haplogroup R have been identified, of which, R1a1-M17 and R1b1b2-M269 (historically called R1b3) are the most well described. Both of these subgroups are indicators of European ancestry with haplogroup R1a1-M17 most representative of Eastern Europeans and R1b1b2-M269 most characteristic of Western Europeans.

"R1b1b2-M269 is found at very high frequencies (50-80%) throughout western Europe particularly in the Ireland, Wales, Scotland, England, Portugal, France, Germany, and northern Italy, with diminishing frequencies towards the east although representation stretches as far as central Asia and India." (Genetree CGG Report)

R1b1b2 Celts is thought to have arrived in central and western Europe around 2300 BCE, by going up the Danube from the Black Sea coast. The migration must have been on a massive scale, maybe due to pressure from other Indo-European people from the north. There might have been several consecutive waves across the Black Sea to the Danube, but the largest one between 2500 BCE and 2300 BCE. From there they moved in Britain. http://www.eupedia.com/europe/origins_haplogroups_europe.shtml#R1b-subclades

That is genetic history and it is pretty technical but the romantic in me warms more to the stories of the bard, storyteller, and ancient historian. For instance, William Livingston writes in his 1850 Vindication of the Celtic Character ...

"The Celtic race were the first known inhabitants of Europe, which was occupied throughout by various tribes or clans. The appropriate name which this remarkable race gave themselves was Celtae; but the terms Galatae, Galatians and Galli, were appellations by which in later ages they were usually distinguished. They covered all Europe to the western extremities. The Keltoi inhabited to the farthest west. The Cymrig Gauls carried their arms along the Danube, Illyricum and Dalmatia. They took possession of the Alps, and colonized the whole north of Italy."

Livingston describes their spread across Europe challenging the Greek and Roman empires. He then links them, with reference to Josephus, to Biblical genealogy...

"Gomer was the father of the Gomarians who are now called by the Greeks, Gauls. Filii autem Japhet septem numerantur ex quo Galatae id est Galli.... Gomer, the eldest son of Japheth, and the father of the Gomarians, who anciently inhabited Galatia, Phrygia, &c. &c., either by the east end of the Euxine, or by crossing the Hellespont, penetrated into Europe, and peopled the countries now called Poland, Hungary, Germany, Switzerland, France, Spain, Portugal, Britain and Scandinavia. Gomer's sons settled themselves in Spain and Italy as early as 142 years after the flood.... they were contemporaries of Abraham and his father Terah.... Here is antiquity for you, equal to that of the ancient patriarchs. Nor do the ancient Scots or Irish appear of a different original. The Phoenicians, another branch of the Celts, inhabited the coast of the Red Sea."

Modern historians may well attribute much of that to fable, legend, mythology, and the imagination and yet there is a strange concurrence with the DNA record. White South Africans are acutely aware of how Genesis 10 and Josephus Bk 1, Ch 6 came to be misapplied to under gird our dubious racist doctrines. Discovering that I was also of Khoikhoi descent was a helpful corrective to any presumed supremest attitudes I might have entertained. Just as the Zulu and the Lemba take pride in their ancient traditions so I find my own origins both humbling and enriching.

Theseus in A Midsummer Night's Dream puts such romance down to fantasy and imagination...

I never may believe
These antique fables, nor these fairy toys.
Lovers and madmen have such seething brains,
Such shaping fantasies, that apprehend
More than cool reason ever comprehends.
The lunatic, the lover and the poet
Are of imagination all compact.
One sees more devils than vast hell can hold;
That is the madman. The lover, all as frantic,
Sees Helen's beauty in a brow of Egypt.
The poet's eye, in fine frenzy rolling,
Doth glance from heaven to earth, from earth to heaven;
And as imagination bodies forth
The forms of things unknown, the poet's pen
Turns them to shapes and gives to airy nothing
A local habitation and a name.
Such tricks hath strong imagination
That, if it would but apprehend some joy,
It comprehends some bringer of that joy.
      - William Shakespeare, "A Midsummer Night's Dream", V, I, 4-17

To which, with Hippolyta, I reply and point to a reality and a Joy far beyond the superficial joy of our sometimes mundane world:

But all the story of the night told over,
And all their minds transfigur'd so together.

...for I'm a romantic at heart. Caves and DNA, Celts and Khoikhoi fire the imagination, transfigures the mind.

©Colin G Garvie HomePage: http://www.garvies.co.za

Saturday, May 15, 2010

Storms River Mouth and Ancestral Memories

Near the mouth is a large cave which was once used by the Strandlopers for shelter. It's about forty metres deep and very dark and eerie. - http://www.turtlesa.com/ezine139.html

Many years before I even became aware of my ancestral connections to the "Strandlopers" (Beachcombers of the Cape) I felt an inexplicable attraction to them and none as powerful as at Storms River Mouth near Knysna on the Garden Route.  We first visited Storms River Mouth in July 1994. I then described my first impressions...

"Storms River Mouth in the Tsitsikama Nature Reserve where mighty oceans pound, mysterious forests sing to the song of loeries, and a massive cave haunts the human heart. At Storms River, ocean, forest and cave come together in a mighty orchestration of emotion. It is a crescendo of sight, sound, and scent. The churning tides and crashing of the waves was for me a picture of the turbulence within my heart. This must surely be the most enchanting place I have ever visited." (Journal 15 July 1994)

Why did the confluence of river gorge, enormous waves, and wild indigenous forests affect me so? Indeed, what magnet drew great-grandfather Laurance Garvie from Scotland to these very forests near Knysna? I don't know but near the mouth of the Storms River is a cave that might well hold the answer. You get to it by means of a scary suspension bridge swaying over the restless tides far below. The synchronicity of sea, skies, and the sun coalesced there for me in that cave, "deep and very dark and eerie".

Knysna author Hjalmar Thesen captures something of the spirit of this link between Europe and Africa in his Strangers from the Sea. I first read this story many years before I even "met" my ancestral Khoikhoi great-grandmother Eva Krotoa. She was a Strandloper. Thesen's story gripped my imagination with a strange familiarity that I couldn't explain. He starts...

"The woman cradled a tin cup in both hands and, as the moon began to spread its purple across the dunes, her eyes shone with a wild brilliance, for she was drugged with the dagga she had smoked. She sipped from the cup of brandy... The woman wore a tattered skirt and her shoulders were covered with a thin shawl. Her breasts protruded uncovered and they were shapely full, curved and pointed with youth... The hypnotic sea droned in splendour and from beyond, where the lights of the fort began, there came the needle point of a violin. The night cast its spell and the woman's voice became the sound of the surf and the lilt of the violin and the weeping of the jackal." (p.1f)

Perhaps there is something in what psychologist's call "ancestral memories". Carl Jung termed it "racial memories". It is said that an object or a place can trigger a genetic memory you share with your ancestors resulting in a deja vu experience. One experiences a "flashback". That is exactly what it seemed like as I spent a few quiet moments in the Storms River Cave. I had been there before! The StateMaster Encyclopedia explains:

"In Jungian psychology, racial memory is a hypothetical type of memory which is not gained through experience or conditioning, but is inherited genetically, as part of a "collective unconscious" of the human species. Racial memory does not define a memory insofar as a specific recollection of an event; instead it references an inherent genetic recollection of the experiences of the ancestral line of any given individual, and how this influences his or her behaviour." http://www.statemaster.com/encyclopedia/Racial-memory

Remarkably, the day before visiting the Cave I had bought and read another of Hjalmar Thesen's books, The Echoing Cliffs. In my Journal of the 14th July 1994, the day before visiting Storms River Mouth, I had unconsciously made an ancestral connection with the Khoi long before I had actually discovered it as fact in 2010. I wrote:

I read Thesen's The Echoing Cliffs. I was amused by a Jungian quaternary, a symbol of wholeness, that came to mind:

Laurance Garvie                     Johanna Garvie
  - child of the forests                    - child of the seas

The Khoi                                 The San
- people of the seas                    - people of the bush


Curious as that experience might be, ancestral memories haven't been scientifically proved but our DNA could very well hold the key. Are we not all collectively joined together by invisible threads and family ties? Whatever this feeling of connectedness to a particular place might be, Storms River Mouth remains for me one of several magical "thin places"  I've come to revere here in South Africa.


©Colin G Garvie HomePage: http://www.garvies.co.za

Saturday, May 8, 2010

Mother's Day - Proudly South African

I am, proudly Scottish. My Garvie paternal ancestry goes back to Scotland and the Hebrides. However, in reality there are more German Kochs and Heuers in my genes.

Genealogy has been a very sensitive issue here in South Africa. We seem to be obsessed with race.  When Dr Hans Heese published  Groep Sonder Grense in 1985 it was received with much consternation and had a profound effect on South African society. The secret truth was that many if not most so-called white, settler South Africans of European descent were not as "lily white" as first believed. They also sported African and Asian blood in their veins. Heese's work was later published in English as Cape Melting Pot. It is a must read for the South African genealogist and historian.

I am of African descent too! I am related to Eva Krotöa as many Afrikaans speaking South Africans are. She was my tenth great-grandmother. Eva was of Khoikhoi descent born on Robben Island…

Colin G Garvie (1946)
+--Cornelia Elizabeth Koch (1919)
+----Bartholomeus Stephanus Koch (1886)
+------Bartholomeus Stephanus Koch (1843)
+--------Alida Christina Diederiks (1813)
+----------Hendrina Catharina Bruynswaard (1788)
+------------Bartholomeus Bruynswaard (1763)
+--------------Johanna Regina Zaayman (1745)
+----------------Bartholomeus Zaayman (1717)
+------------------Pieter Zaayman  (c1688)
+--------------------Pieternella Meerhoff (c1655)
+----------------------EVA KROTÖA(c1642)

Pieternella's story has been beautifully recorded in Dalene Matthee's novel, Pieternella, Daughter of Eva. Eva Krotöa is equally fascinating. Her story is related in Trudie Bloem's book (to mention one), Krotöa - Eva, The Woman from Robben Island.

I share Andre van Rensburg's view, "The nearest I have come to royalty or chiefdom is through Eva who was an indigenous Khoikhoi (Hottentot)."

Andre writes...

"Eva also known as Krotoa was born c 1642 at the Cape. She was a member of the Goringhaikona. Strandloper (beachcomber), Hottentot, (this particular tribe consisted about fifty individuals according to Malherbe). Her uncle Herry also known as Autohoemao was the captain of this tribe. She rode on the back of an ox - denoting a high station amongst Khoikhoi. Like the biblical Eva she can be considered to be the stammoeder of the Afrikaner (at least mine), since her union in marriage with Pieter van Meerhoff was the commencement of the Afrikaner, having their roots in Europe but they are also the seed of Africa."

More about Eva's life and influence can be read at Andre van Rensburg's pages:
http://www.oocities.com/athens/rhodes/1266/genetic-eva.htm
http://wc.rootsweb.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?op=GET&db=erasmussa&id=I1358
Also see: Wikipedia

Eva, my tenth great-grandmother from Robben Island, connects me to Africa in as much as I am connected to Scotland and Germany through others. I am a South African.  If I have any land claim at all, it would be through Eva's ancestors, to all the beaches of the Cape of Good Hope!

I am proudly Scottish but proudly South African too!

God bless Africa! God bless our Mothers!



Picture: Painting from PW Laidler, Growth and Government of Cape Town, 1939
©Colin G Garvie HomePage: http://www.garvies.co.za

Tuesday, May 4, 2010

Legendary Soccer Great: Johnny Garvie 1927 - 1996

South Africa is hosting the FIFA 2010 World Soccer Cup. The country is in the grips of soccer fever, enamoured by "the Beautiful Game". This affords me, as a Garvie family historian, to pay tribute to one of the legendary greats, Johnny Garvie (http://www.redimps.co.uk/page/LeagueLegends/0,,10440~971184,00.html).

Johnny played in both the Scottish and English Leagues from 1946 to 1959. He played as an inside right or centre forward. Wikipedia summarises his career (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnny_Garvie)...

Garvie was born in Bellshill, Lanarkshire. He began his football career with Hibernian after the Second World War. Though he played on loan for Hamilton Academical and Stenhousemuir in the Scottish League, he never appeared for Hibs' first team. Garvie moved to England to join Second Division club Preston North End in 1949, but made only five first-team appearances for Preston before dropping a division to sign for Lincoln City a year later.

In his first season, Garvie was the club's leading scorer with 21 goals in all competitions, only one more than Andy Graver, with whom he formed a fine goalscoring partnership. He scored another 21 the following season "rather fewer than Graver's 39" and was ever-present as Lincoln won the Third Division North title in 1951- 52. After three seasons of Graver top-scoring for Lincoln, Garvie was leading scorer for the second time in 1954 - 55, though with only 13 goals as they struggled in the bottom half of the Second Division. In six years with Lincoln, Garvie scored a total of 80 goals from 192 appearances in League and FA Cup. He spent the 1956 - 57 season with Carlisle United in the Third Division before moving into non-League football.

Garvie joined Boston United, playing in the Midland League, in 1957, resuming his partnership with Graver.[4] In two seasons, he scored 31 goals from 95 games in all competitions, including goals in Boston's first four games in their first season in the Southern League. He then played for Corby Town, Stamford Town, and Ilkeston Town, where he was again reunited with Graver. However, the pair were prevented from renewing their prolific partnership once more by a foot injury which restricted Garvie to just five appearances.

What is interesting and fascinating for the historian is that Johnny was born in Bellshill, Scotland. Bellshill was renowned for its football greats. In 1996, a television programme was made about the three world famous football managers who were born in Bellshill - Matt Busby, Bill Shankly and Jock Stein. Hughie Gallacher, Peter Grant, Hugh Murray, and Sir Matt Busby of Manchester United were all Bellshill boys. Bellshill is testimony to how a community can influence and direct the destiny of its children for good.

South Africans trust that the 2010 World Cup will similarly bind and inspire its citizens to all that is best in "the Beautiful Game".

Joga Bonito!

©Colin G Garvie HomePage: http://www.garvies.co.za

Saturday, May 1, 2010

When It Comes to Mars, I am Agnostic...

From the minute I first saw the Mariner 6 and 7 close-ups of Mars I was captivated. Mars had caught my imagination from a very young age. The wandering Red Planet of the night skies always intrigued me but now I saw Mars as never before, close at hand. Mariner 4  flew by Mars in July, 1965. The photos were fuzzy, low resolution, and indistinct but nevertheless very exciting. Mariner 6 and 7  flew past on July 31, 1969 and August 5, 1969 respectively. The photos now were more distinct and fascinating. A love affair with Mars had begun.

It was sheer magic and awe when in 1970, South Africans Frank Duminy, Brian Levitan, and I drove one October morning into the Mars Deep Space Tracking Station, Goldstone, California for the first time. We were dwarfed beneath this magnificent marvel of deep space technology...


It didn't take much imagination to wonder and ask, what on earth are we getting up to....for heaven's sake?

Much has happened since. Our attention has shifted from the Moon to Mars. One wonders why? Has it to do with its mysterious moon, Phobos? There has been much speculation surrounding Mars. We now know much more. The tenacious Mars Rovers, Spirit and Opportunity have literally only scratched its ancient scarred surface. Now some are speculating whether the enigmatic Phobos isn't perhaps "artificial"!

You can read about it here...
Part 1: http://www.enterprisemission.com/Phobos.html
Part 2: http://www.enterprisemission.com/Phobos2.html

Is Phobos artificial? I am agnostic. I don't know. We are not 100% sure right now but we could know pretty soon with a Phobos landing planned within a couple of years. Till then I prefer to keep an open mind. It seems a little far fetched...but is it? There are stranger things out there. And if it is artificial, what then? Back in 1970 when I stood beneath the 210' Mars Dish Antenna, I certainly felt there was something more up there than might just meet the human eye!

©Colin G Garvie HomePage: http://www.garvies.co.za